Demystifying Coin Condition: A Guide to the Sheldon Grading Scale

For those passionate about numismatic collecting, a coin's beauty goes beyond its design and history. Its condition, a key factor in value, is where the art of coin grading comes in. Numismatic ratings, assigned through a standardized system, are a precise indicator of  a coin's condition, which facilitates fair trades and informed collecting.

The Sheldon Grading Scale, also known as the Sheldon coin condition scale or Sheldon grading system, is the industry standard for how coins are graded. Developed by Dr. William Sheldon in the 1940s,the Sheldon Grading Scale assigns a numerical grade from 1 to 70. The number reflects a coin's overall condition. To visually represent these grades with detailed descriptions look to coin grading charts, which are available online as well as from professional grading services.
Understanding the Sheldon scale empowers collectors to navigate the world of coin collecting with confidence. Let's dive into its elements for greater clarification.

Breakdown of the Sheldon Scale:

• Poor (AG-3 to FR-2): is heavily worn, minimal details visible.

• Good (G-4 to G-6):  has significant wear, but major design elements are intact and legible.

• Very Good (VG-8 to VG-10): shows moderate wear, with more defined features.

• Fine (F-12 to F-15): has moderate wear, yet clear details in major devices.

• Very Fine (VF-20 to VF-35): may range from light to moderate wear, with all major details clear and some finer details visible.

• Extremely Fine (EF-40 to EF-45): only light wear, with sharp and clear details.

• About Uncirculated (AU-50 to AU-58): displays minimal wear on the highest points of the coin.

• Mint State (MS-60 to MS-70): appears to have no wear whatsoever, with MS-70 being a perfect coin.
   

• Understanding Mint State (MS) Grades: MS coin grading scale refers to uncirculated coins.
  Here's a closer look:

  • MS-60 to MS-63: Uncirculated with minor imperfections or contact marks.

  • MS-64 to MS-67: High-quality uncirculated coins, with progressively fewer marks.

  • MS-68 to MS-69: Exceptionally well-preserved, with minimal imperfections visible only under magnification.

  • MS-70: The pinnacle, a flawless coin.

• Common Coin Grading Abbreviations:

  • AU: About Uncirculated

  • MS: Mint State

  • MS67: Refers to a coin graded 67 on the Sheldon scale, indicating very high quality.

  • MS69: An exceptional coin, nearly perfect with just one or two minor imperfections.

Beyond the Sheldon Scale:
While the Sheldon scale provides a basis, look to professional grading services which offer additional designations for specific coin types and characteristics such as luster or color.
Penny grading charts, for example, might consider details specific to pennies.

Remember, coin grading is a complex skill best left to professionals and experts in the field of numismatic collecting. However, a solid understanding of the Sheldon scale will provide you with the ability to interpret grading reports, communicate effectively with other collectors, and appreciate the nuances of coin conditions! So, happy collecting, and may your next discovered treasure be in pristine condition!
 

To View Upcoming Lots in Coin, Currency and Stamps, click here.
Top Image: 1855 U.S. Liberty Head double eagle $20 gold coin.